Members opposed to AI making pension decisions without human review

Pension scheme members are uncomfortable with artificial intelligence (AI) making pension-related decisions without human review, research from Local Pensions Partnership Administration (LPPA) and Burges Salmon has found.

The survey of 1,690 members showed that only 2% would be comfortable with AI making pension-related decisions without human involvement, while 61% said they would never be comfortable with this approach.

However, this shifted to 69% who said they would be comfortable now or in the future for AI to support pension-related decision making, as long as a person remained responsible for the outcome.

In the joint LPPA and Burges Salmon report, lack of human oversight (76%), data protection and privacy (69%), information accuracy (69%), and trust and transparency (58%) were identified as the key concerns, with respondents suggesting pensions were too important to be left solely to AI.

Overall, 30% of members reported using AI tools for general use, but 53% said they were not confident in the accuracy of AI-generated information, and only 9% said they used AI tools to research topics such as retirement planning and pension benefits.

The survey also found that 50% of members had used, or would consider using, AI to prepare a complaint or Internal Dispute Resolution Process (IDRP) submission, while 64% said they would not disclose its use, potentially increasing the volume and complexity of complaints faced by pension schemes and administrators.

The research also discovered that 39%t of members were unaware that many AI tools process and store personal data.

Discussing the research, LPPA chief technology officer, Martin Davidson, said: "AI has quickly become part of our everyday lives, and these results show that while members are interested in the opportunities it offers, they're clear that confidence, security and access to trusted information remains essential.

"Members recognise the value AI can bring, but they want reassurance that oversight and accountability remain at the heart of important decisions.”

Davidson said the findings reinforced the importance of helping members understand new technologies while continuing to provide trusted pension administration and access to information.

In fact, 76% of research respondents said they would find it useful for administrators to explain the risks of using AI when making financial and retirement decisions, and 81% said they would welcome general guidance on using AI responsibly.

Adding to this, Burges Salmon partner, Chris Brown, said: “With members now using AI on a daily basis and The Pensions Regulator’s guidance on the topic expected soon, now is the time to get up to speed with the opportunities and risks of the technology and to ensure that appropriate governance arrangements are in place.”



Share Story:

Recent Stories


FREE E-NEWS SIGN UP

Subscribe to our newsletter to receive breaking news and other industry announcements by email.

  Please tick here to confirm you are happy to receive third party promotions from carefully selected partners.


The changing face of retirement and estate planning

AI, finfluencers and the future of broking
The mortgage industry is evolving faster than ever. In this MoneyAge video, we examine the opportunities and challenges redefining the broker landscape, from AI-powered lending and changing customer expectations to housing affordability, property supply and the rise of financial influencers. Our guest from Chorley Building Society shares practical insights on what brokers need to do to stay relevant and thrive in a rapidly changing market.

Pure Retirement and the role of lifetime mortgages
Senior content editor Dan McGrath is joined by strategic account manager at Pure Retirement, Tash Phillips, to discuss the lifetime mortgage market, the role of equity release in the industry and how the firm’s range of products, including its interest servicing lifetime mortgage, can serve the sector moving forward in the ever-changing lending space.

Helping landlords make their cash work harder
MoneyAge Editor, Adam Cadle, talks to Family Building Society BDMs, Arif Kara and Nathan Waller, about the resilient BTL market, the wide variety of landlords that Family Building Society caters for, and how niche products like an Offset mortgage can help improve cashflow.